For those of my friends reading this on FB, (because everybody on LJ and DW has heard of this by now), Elizabeth Moon is an award-winning scifi novelist who recently made xenophobic and Islamophobic remarks on her blog, specifically targeting the NYC Islamic community centre that is actually quite a few blocks away from Ground Zero and is not, in fact a mosque, and was only built in that location because it was the most affordable place in the city considering that particular Islamic community's budget. One of the things that she's been blathering about is Islamic imperialism, and I think this needs to be addressed - but it also ties in with the modern Western right's overall insistence on holding its opponents, be it feminists, anti-racists, anti-war activists or just plain old white male leftists, to a higher standard of behavior than it holds itself.
  Is invading a country in the name of spreading a religion or ideology a bad thing? Absolutely, no doubt about it. Saladin is held to be among the noblest of Muslim leaders and even under his leadership violence against women took place when his soldiers took back Jerusalem. In war, bad things happen - which is exactly why the left opposed the war in Iraq and Afghanistan. War is destructive of civil society, of industry, and of the family, which is why I am surprised that more conservatives of all countries are not anti-war.
  But here's the thing: until Gandhi, war was considered an acceptable way of resolving international disputes. Christianity, Hinduism and Buddhism, among the Old World religions (delux vivens and unusualmusic, please comment on Africanist and First Nations attitudes) have pacifist attitudes but in practice their hierarchies have either gone along with militarism or actively encouraged it. Judaism and Islam have generally had pragmatist attitudes towards violence. (Islam could not have survived a thousand years if it had constantly and ceaselessly gone through the incessant violence that is afflicting Afghanistan and Iraq. Most of the myths about constant warfare among Middle Eastern tribes, or at least the kind that's taking place in Iraq, is a myth; there have usually been interludes at least of peace with some minor gangsta-style trouble).  "Everybody does it" is not a rational moral excuse, but when the expectation all over the world in male society is that you settle your differences with your fists, it is not surprising that Muslims have waged war to enhance their power, just as Christians, Hindus, and yes, Buddhists have.
  Gandhi and his followers like MLK were great men, and necessary men, not just for mere moral glamour, but more practically because non-violence activism is one of the best ways of building an egalitarian civil society, which after all is what liberation is supposed to be about. But a completely unintended consequence of their successes is that the left was expected to be morally pure, to refrain from any action that might even remotely resemble violence, to remain enslaved to a ballot box system corrupted by corporatism. And not only that, they were either too white and male to adequately represent the oppressed or they were reverse oppressing white men; either they were too frivolous in their love of music and litcrit theory or they were humorless types who couldn't see the fun in "politically-incorrect" asshatry; they were too poor and therefore were preaching "politics of envy" or they were too rich and therefore hypocrites who had nothing to complain about. The connection between singling out Islam as uniquely imperialistic and oppressive and attacking the moral character and personalities of the left may not be obvious, but they are linked in the way that the modern Western right gives itself the freedom to be douchebags and denies others the freedom to be human.
(It is worth noting that no Muslim country has actually invaded with an occupational force a (culturally) Christian country since the days of the Ottoman Empire)
ETA: this was inspired by[personal profile] sarasvati 's piece sarasvati.dreamwidth.org/31766.html.



Profile

sajia_kabir

March 2019

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
2425 2627282930
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 21st, 2025 10:18 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios